The Top 10 Best Organic Mascara

As an Amazon Associate I may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases.

When it comes to beauty products, going organic is the key, especially if you want to enhance your eyes. That being said, it is not really difficult to find the best organic mascara in the market. 

When choosing a mascara, you want to make sure it’s cruelty-free and made from natural ingredients. These products are non-toxic and safe to use. 

Organic mascaras are made from plant-derived oils, waxes, and pigments. They are gluten-free, sulfate-free, and contain no GMOs. These natural mascaras are also a great option for sensitive skin. 

There are many different brands of organic mascaras available in the market. So, it is important to make the right buying decision. 

We have created a list of the top 10 best organic mascaras in 2023. You can compare them and choose the best one as per your requirement. 

What Is Organic Mascara?

According to WiseGeek, organic mascara is a beauty product made from natural ingredients that help to define your eyelashes. It is made from natural ingredients that are safe for your eyes.

Choosing the best organic mascara that is both natural and organic can help you to protect your eyes from harmful toxins. It can also be a key step in creating beautiful, long lashes.

An organic formula doesn’t contain parabens or artificial colors, and it is free of any phthalates or silicones. There are many manufacturers that use natural ingredients to make their products. 

You can find these mascaras at online stores, e-commerce sites as well as at conventional stores. However, make sure you check the label to be sure it is truly natural.

What Are The Benefits of Organic Mascara?

If you are looking for a product that will make your lashes look longer and fuller, then you need to consider natural or organic mascara. These products are completely free of harmful chemicals. They also contain natural ingredients, making them safe and gentle to use.

Many natural mascaras are vegan and ethically sourced. Some are even produced in eco-friendly tubes. Some natural ingredients are particularly beneficial for the eyes, such as argan oil. It helps fight free radicals and strengthens lashes.

According to Grove, natural mascara can help to condition and stimulate lash growth, which is ideal for those with sensitive eyes. In addition to its ability to condition your lashes, this type of makeup also creates definition. It is a great choice for contact lens wearers, as it is non-toxic and hypoallergenic.

If you want to know how to apply mascara like a pro, check out this amazing YouTube video. These tips and tricks will help you to enhance your lashes perfectly with mascara. 

Harmful Chemicals Used in Regular Mascara

According to HealthShots, there are some dangerous chemicals used in regular mascaras. These ingredients are harmful to your eyes. So, make sure you check the list of ingredients when buying mascara and avoid the ones that are potentially harmful. 

  • Paraben
  • Prime Yellow Carnauba Wax
  • Carbon Black
  • Benzalkonium Chloride
  • Aluminum Powder

Common Non-Toxic Mascara Ingredients

If you’re considering buying non-toxic mascara, you’re in the right place. You’re about to learn the ingredients you should look for. These ingredients are all natural and safe for you to use on your eyelashes.

  • Organic Oils and Butter
  • Vitamin E
  • Essential Oils
  • Aloe Vera Gel
  • Green Tea
  • Organic Beeswax

Why Should You Choose Organic Mascara?

When it comes to picking out the right mascara for your skin, there are many reasons to choose an organic product. Organic beauty products are made from ingredients that are healthy for the skin and for the environment while also being safe and gentle for those with sensitive skin. If you aren’t sure why you should choose organic mascara, check out these benefits of choosing organic mascara.

  • No Harsh Chemicals
    According to Green People, choosing the best organic mascara is a great way to protect your eyes. Many conventional mascaras contain toxic chemicals that are harmful to your health. But many brands are now switching to organic products that you can enjoy without any harsh chemicals.
  • Eco-Friendly
    Organic mascara is a great way to save on plastic waste. Many brands offer reusable packaging and refillable bottles. You’ll find that most mascara brands have an environmental focus. Most of them are carbon neutral, and some donate to environmental non-profits.
  • Safe
    developed for the safety of users. They are made from natural, organic ingredients and can be a great option for sensitive eyes.
  • Natural Fragrances
    A natural fragrance is one that is free of synthetic ingredients. Organic mascaras contain natural fragrances. Using them will not only make your makeup safer, but it will also help prevent lung irritation, hormonal disruption, and possible carcinogens.

Top 10 Best Organic Mascaras in 2023

If you’re looking for a mascara that will leave your eyelashes long and defined, look for one that uses only natural ingredients. These products are free of harmful chemicals and toxins, such as parabens. Here is the list of the top 10 best organic mascaras in 2023. 

#1. Best Overall: Essence | Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara

Best Overall: Essence | Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
Editor’s Rating: 4.9
Product SKU: B00T0C9XRK
Product Brand: Essence
Product Price: 4.99 Product Currency: $
Price Valid Until: 2024-04-30
Product In-Stock: InStock
  • Experience the enchantment of captivating lashes with Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara. Achieve a mesmerizing look that rivals false lashes with this iconic mascara. The unique formula coats each lash from root to tip, delivering incredible length and volume for a dramatic effect. Say goodbye to clumps and hello to a bold, intensified gaze. Elevate your lash game with Lash Princess and unveil a world of breathtaking beauty
  • Features:
    • Not Tested On Animals
    • Built-In Brush
    • Long-Wearing
    • Long Lasting
    • Volumizing
    • Lengthening
    Pros
    • Vegan formula
    • Non-Flaking
    • Non-Clumping
    • Unscented
    Cons
    • It smears, especially in hot weather.

    #2. Best Formula: Poppy Austin Mascara

    Best Formula: Poppy Austin Mascara
    Editor’s Rating: 4.9
  • If you are looking for a mascara that is 100% organic, cruelty-free, fragrance-free, and vegan, Poppy Austin is a great choice. It is smudge-proof and flake-resistant and will give you long, luscious lashes. Also, it is enriched with the finest organic argan oil, which improves the health of your lashes. 
  • Not only does it make your lashes luxuriously full, but it also helps promote growth. In addition, it provides a 24-hour lift. With its unique formula, the Poppy Austin Mascara gives you a gorgeous, fluttery lash look that lasts all day. It will help you to turn heads when you walk into a crowd. 
  • The organic formula is also gentle and smudge-resistant. You will be able to enjoy a full-bristle applicator that is perfect for achieving a wide range of lashes. Additionally, the Poppy Austin Mascara is all-natural and sustainably harvested. The best thing about this mascara is that it is waterproof. It is also hypoallergenic and suitable for sensitive skin.
  • Features:
    • 100% organic
    • Lash strengthening mascara
    • Flake-resistant & smudge-proof
    • Nourishing formula
    • Gentle on sensitive eyes
    • Hypoallergenic 
    Pros
    • Contain natural ingredients
    • Offers thickening and lengthening
    • Lasts for 24 hours
    • Waterproof formula
    • Easy to apply
    • Vegan formula
    Cons
    • Mediocre brush quality
    • Can be difficult to remove

    #3. Best Moisturizing Formula: Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Nourishing Mascara

    Best Moisturizing Formula: Burt's Bees 100% Natural Nourishing Mascara
    Editor’s Rating: 4.8
  • If you’re looking for long-lasting mascara that’s also made from natural ingredients, Burt’s Bees has you covered. This 100% natural mascara is free from harsh chemicals, parabens, and phthalates and is formulated to give you thick, full lashes. Its all-natural formula also contains Jojoba Oil, which can be used to nourish your lashes.
  • In addition to its all-natural ingredients, Burt’s Bees has done the unthinkable: designed a mascara that’s safe for contact lens wearers. It’s also the first mascara of its kind to contain the super-moisturizing ingredient Glycerin, which can be used on the sensitive eye area to moisturize and condition your lashes.
  • It is a classic black mascara that is easy to use. This product comes with an easy-to-use applicator and is perfect for all eye colors and skin tones. It will nourish as well as strengthen and condition your lashes. This mascara is perfect for defining your eyelashes to complement your overall makeup.
  • Features:
    • Classic black mascara
    • Enriched with nourishing ingredients
    • Strengthens and conditions your lashes
    • Lengthening mascara
    • Made from 100% natural ingredients
    • Ophthalmologist-tested 
    Pros
    • Naturally moisturizes your lashes
    • Easy-to-use applicator
    • Gentle for delicate eyes
    • Long-lasting definition 
    • Safe for contact lens wearers
    • Not tested on animals
    Cons
    • Flakes slightly
    • Can be a bit dry

    #4. Best for Sensitive Eyes: Gaya Cosmetics Vegan Waterproof Black Mascara

    Best for Sensitive Eyes: Gaya Cosmetics Vegan Waterproof Black Mascara
    Editor’s Rating: 4.7
  • If you are sensitive to mascara, it can be a challenge to find a product that won’t cause irritation. Some brands contain ingredients that can be harsh to your eyes, but there are several options for you to choose from. One such product is Gaya Cosmetics Vegan Waterproof Black Mascara.
  • It is a natural hypoallergenic mascara that is specially developed for sensitive eyes.
  • This mascara prevents your lashes from flaking or smudging. This makes it perfect for people wearing contact lenses. It is formulated with nourishing ingredients and doesn’t contain any harsh or harmful chemicals. It is long-lasting and easy to use.
  • This mascara gives you natural-looking lashes. It adds volume to your lashes and makes them appear longer and fuller. This product is ophthalmologist-tested and cruelty-free. This vegan mascara for sensitive eyes avoids irritating ingredients. It contains natural ingredients like beetroot extract, which helps to treat eyelashes and make them appear fuller.
  • Features:
    • Luxury vegan mascara
    • Professional curved wand
    • Lengthen lashes with no clumps
    • Lengthening mascara
    • Long-lasting and easy to use
    • Made from natural ingredients
    Pros
    • Ophthalmological tested
    • Gentle formula for sensitive eyes
    • Suitable for contact lenses
    • Gives a full boost to lashes
    • Smudge-proof silicone brush
    • Provides a natural eye look
    Cons
    • Can be hard to remove
    • Only water-resistant

    #5. Best Natural Formula: Pacifica Beauty Stellar Gaze Length & Strength Mascara

    Best Natural Formula: Pacifica Beauty Stellar Gaze Length & Strength Mascara
    Editor’s Rating: 4.7
  • The Pacifica Beauty Stellar Gaze Length & Strength Black Mascara is the best natural formula on the market. It is formulated with beneficial natural ingredients like vitamin B and coconut oil. It is an eminently worthy purchase for your makeup arsenal. If you’re on the hunt for the perfect lash, be sure to check out this product before you hit the town.
  • This mascara comes in a small, lightweight tube and is equipped with a super plush vegan brush. It’s also a winner in a crowded beauty bag. The best part is that it won’t break the bank. Despite its low price tag, you can rest assured you’re getting a high-quality organic product for your eyelashes. Plus, it’s cruelty-free.
  • Its long-lasting formula withstands the wear and tear of day and night. Whether you’re on the clock or out on the town, this is your beauty best friend. This mascara offers deep intense color and helps to lengthen your lashes. The best thing is that it is made without parabens, talc, mineral oil, and other harmful chemicals.
  • Features:
    • Infused with natural ingredients
    • Lengthening formula
    • Comes with a super plush vegan brush
    • Deep intensity color
    • Formulated without chemicals
    • Not tested on animals
    Pros
    • Provides a natural lash effect
    • Lengthens strengthens and adds volume
    • Infused with coconut oil and vitamin B
    • Vegan and cruelty-free
    • Safe to use
    • Doesn’t contain silicones, sulfates, and paraben
    Cons
    • Smudges under eye
    • Takes a long time to dry

    #6. Best Lightweight Mascara: ILIA – Limitless Lash Mascara

    Best Lightweight Mascara: ILIA - Limitless Lash Mascara
    Editor’s Rating: 4.6
  • ILIA – Limitless Lash Mascara is an award-winning, natural, lightweight mascara. It is designed to lift, define, and lengthen lashes with minimal effort. The formula contains organic bee and carnauba waxes, fortifying arginine, and shea butter. This mascara also has a gentle formula that is suitable for sensitive eyes.
  • ILIA – Limitless Lash is a clean beauty product that is free from formaldehyde, sulfates, phthalates, parabens, and silicone. It is also flake-free and safe for contact lens wearers. Using the patented dual-sided brush, users can create a full, long look or a dramatic, cat-eye effect. One side is designed to provide a soft, smudge-free coat, while the other side is designed to define and separate each lash.
  • This mascara is designed to be easily removed with water. The formula is 99% naturally derived and ophthalmologist-tested. This mascara is made with natural ingredients and is cruelty-free. ILIA – Limitless Lash has a formula that allows you to determine the level of intensity you want to achieve. It is a clean formula that doesn’t smudge or clump.
  • Features:
    • Clean mascara formula
    • Buildable and flake-free
    • Lightweight and nourishing
    • 99% natural-derived
    • Safe for sensitive eyes
    • Organic and cruelty-free
    Pros
    • Smudge-proof and easy to apply
    • Comes with a dual-sided brush
    • Keeps lashes lifted throughout the day
    • Easy to remove
    • Non-toxic
    • Condition each lash
    Cons
    • Smells bad
    • Need multiple coats

    #7. Best Voluminous Mascara: Organic Mascara by Endlessly Beautiful

    Best Voluminous Mascara: Organic Mascara by Endlessly Beautiful
    Editor’s Rating: 4.6
  • Organic Mascara by Endlessly Beautiful is one of the best voluminous mascaras out there. It’s vegan, gluten-free, and paraben free. This mascara is also smudge-proof, sweat-proof, and water-resistant. This mascara contains vitamins, botanicals, and nourishing ingredients like chamomile and vitamin E to help your lashes grow naturally. 
  • Its silky, smooth application provides length and definition. With an easy application, you can get a dramatic look in one coat. Organic Mascara by Endlessly Beautiful stays on all day and can make up a great vegan gift. 
  • Organic Mascara by Endlessly Beauty is also easy to apply. With its silky consistency, it’s ideal for those who don’t like the mess of liquid eyeliner. Its organic formula ensures that your eyelashes are well-moisturized, healthy, and beautiful.
  • Features:
    • Fuller and longer lashes
    • All natural mascara
    • Adds volume to your lashes
    • Stays on all-day
    • Paraben free
    • Good for contact wearers
    Pros
    • No clumps, flakes, or smudges
    • Best mascara for thickening and lengthening
    • Free of harmful chemicals
    • Long-lasting formula
    • 100% cruelty-free       
    • Easy to apply and remove
    Cons
    • Only 85% of organic

    #8. Best Lengthening: 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Ultra Lengthening Mascara

    Best Lengthening: 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Ultra Lengthening Mascara
    Editor’s Rating: 4.5
  • If you’re looking for a natural and cruelty-free mascara, try 100% Pure’s Fruit Pigmented Ultra Lengthening Mascara. It’s packed with all-natural ingredients that condition and lengthen lashes, separating them and adding volume.
  • This all-natural formula comes in two shades: Black Tea and Dark Chocolate. This mascara is water-resistant and doesn’t smudge. However, it does have a scent. It’s also infused with Pro-vitamin B5, vitamin E, oat, and wheat proteins to nourish and condition your lashes.
  • 100% Pure’s products are free from harmful chemical additives, sulfates, and formaldehyde. They also don’t contain parabens or solvents. This all-natural mascara is perfect for anyone with sensitive eyes. It’s made with black tea, berry, and cocoa pigments that color your lashes and condition them.
  • Features:
    • Naturally, boost your lashes
    • Add moisture and volume
    • Made with clean, nourishing ingredients
    • Packed with antioxidants
    • Cruelty-free and ethically-sourced
    • Fade-proof length
    Pros
    • Infused with luscious oil
    • Comes with a lush lengthening eye wand 
    • Coats each lash without clumps or flakes
    • No clumping, flaking, and smudging
    • Vegan formula  
    • Perfect water-resistant cover
    Cons
    • Might sting your eyes

    #9. Best Dual Purpose Mascara: Fifth & Skin NATURLASH Natural Mascara

    Best Dual Purpose Mascara: Fifth & Skin NATURLASH Natural Mascara
    Editor’s Rating: 4.4
  • The Fifth & Skin NATURLASH Natural Mascara is a great choice if you are looking for a hypoallergenic option. It’s also vegan, paraben-free, and cruelty-free. This formula uses jojoba oil to condition and nourishes your lashes. Argan oil adds volume and length, and it also stimulates growth.
  • In addition to being gentle on your eyes, this mascara is also smudge-proof. Another feature that you will appreciate is its slanted brush. It helps you to coat each lash with a product. Fifth & Skin’s formula is water-resistant, so you won’t have to worry about the mascara flaking off. It’s also a great option for people with sensitive eyes.
  • Besides being waterproof, this mascara also contains no toxins, petroleum products, or synthetic fragrances. The best thing about this mascara is that it is dual-purpose. You can use it as mascara as well as liquid eyeliner.
  • Features:
    • Best natural mascara
    • Hypoallergenic for sensitive skin
    • 100% natural and non-toxic
    • Long-lasting results
    • Water-resistant
    • Dual-purpose
    Pros
    • Silky smooth application
    • Lengthening mascara for longer lashes
    • Great for sensitive eyes
    • Cruelty-free
    • Waterproof
    • Can be used as liquid eyeliner
    Cons
    • Thicker than most products

    #10. Premium Pick: Premium Organic Mascara by Naturally Rooted Store

    Premium Pick: Premium Organic Mascara by Naturally Rooted Store
  • If you are looking to start your journey into organic mascaras, you may want to consider buying the Premium Organic Mascara from the Naturally Rooted Store. This mascara gives your lashes a natural boost and provides volume and nourishment. The formula is gentle on your eyes, and it doesn’t contain harsh chemicals.
  • This mascara is 85% organic and cruelty-free. It contains ingredients like chamomile and sunflower oil that strengthen and moisturize your lashes. It is made in the USA and is great for sensitive eyes. This mascara is premium quality and lasts for a long time. It won’t clump or look bad on your eyes.
  • It is paraben-free, gluten-free, dye-free, and water-resistant. This mascara is easy to apply and is safe for your eyes and skin. The black color of this mascara is perfect if you are going for a bold look.
  • Features:
    • 85% organic mascara
    • No harmful chemicals
    • Cruelty-free
    • Great for sensitive eyes
    • Bold and beautiful lashes
    Pros
    • Enriched with natural ingredients
    • Paraben-free and gluten-free
    • Made in the USA
    • Nourishes your lashes
    • Water-resistant formula
    Cons
    • The bristles are short

    What Can I Use Instead of Mascara?

    What Can I Use Instead of Mascara

    If you are tired of your current mascara, or you don’t have the time to apply it every day, there are other alternatives to help you get longer, thicker, and more gorgeous lashes. According to The List, vaseline is a great alternative to mascara. You can also use coconut oil or olive oil. 

    What Are the Different Types of Mascara?

    According to West More Beauty, there are many different types of mascara on the market. You must choose the right formula to achieve the best results. Here is the list of different types of mascara: lash-lengthening mascara, volumizing mascara, waterproof & smudge-proof mascara, curling mascara, non-clumping mascara, and lash-defining mascara.

    What Is Organic Mascara Made Of?

    Organic mascara is made from all-natural ingredients, avoiding chemicals. These mascaras are made of sunflower oil, beeswax, carnauba wax, jojoba oil, shea butter, avocado oil, etc.

    What Ingredients Should You Avoid in Mascara?

    What Ingredients Should You Avoid in Mascara

    Oftentimes, the ingredients in mascara can be hazardous to health. You need to avoid ingredients like formaldehyde, propylene glycol, aluminum powder, coal tar dyes, retinyl acetate, fragrance, etc.

    Conclusion

    Organic beauty products are the latest trend. If you want to keep your skin and eyelashes healthy, it is best to choose organic mascaras. These products don’t contain sulfates, parabens, or harsh chemicals which can cause damage to the eyelids. This is especially important if you wear contact lenses. Natural mascara is also ideal for people with sensitive eyes. In addition, it can be applied easily without causing any lash fallout. In this guide, we have reviewed the top 10 best organic mascaras in 2023. You can choose any of these mascaras to keep your eyelashes well-defined without compromising on health and safety.

    {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
    Best Organic Eye Creams

    The 10 Best Organic Eye Creams

    best organic makeup removers

    8 Best Organic Makeup Removers

    10 Best Organic and Natural Concealers

    The 10 Best Organic Concealers

    organic makeup for kids

    Organic Makeup For Kids

    best organic eyeshadow

    The 20 Best Organic Eyeshadows

    Best Organic All Natural Lip Tints and Lipsticks

    The 9 Best Organic Lipsticks