Best Organic Eyeliner

As an Amazon Associate I may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases.

Originating in Ancient Egypt around 12.000 years ago, eyeliner was used by upper-class women and men to define their eyes better and protect them from exposure to desert sun and wind. Since then, it's been used by many, from Queen Cleopatra to modern icons like Gwen Stefani or Ariana Grande, to create a signature look that would not be possible without the best organic eyeliner.

Natural Beauty With Best Organic Eyeliner

In recent years, the natural beauty market has transformed from niche to fully mainstream thanks to the rise of informed consumers that won't settle for less than the safest organic ingredients.

The demand for all-natural, non-toxic beauty products has never been higher. Still, "natural" is a somewhat vague term, often used very loosely in the makeup industry. With that in mind, the only way to be sure you get the best products is by familiarizing yourself with the ingredients of beauty products available, as well as natural certifications that are out there.

quatation marks

“Since there's no law regulating and strictly defining terms like "organic" and "natural", many companies exploit this and use somewhat misleading words like "chemical-free" or "all-natural" while still using components that are neither of those things.”

The 10 Best Organic Eyeliner Brands

I've researched and tested 40 different products to help you find the absolute best all-natural eyeliner. Besides being made from truly natural, organic ingredients, these fantastic products don't contain any artificial ingredients (formaldehyde, parabens, synthetic dyes, fragrances, petrochemicals). Instead, makeup specialists and professionals have crafted them. Enjoy!

#1 Ecco Bella Soft Eyeliner Pencil - Best Organic Eyeliner Pencil

Ecco Bella has you covered if you're looking for an organic pencil that's environmentally friendly and won't irritate your skin.

Creating natural products since 1992, their priority is your health and the health of our environment. Rich in palm kernel glycerides, this fantastic eyeliner comes in five colors and offers smooth lines, softly defining your eyes without tugging.

Made from vegetable wax, without petroleum oils, the formula is certified vegan as well as gluten-free. Even though it's a soft pencil, you can easily sharpen it without crumbling. A strong contender for the best organic eye pencil, creating a fantastic smudged cover, as well as clear and defined lines when sharpened.

#2 W3ll People Hypnotist Eye pencil - Best Natural Eyeliner Pencil

A strong contender for the prestigious title of the best natural eyeliner, the Hypnotist Pencil by W3ll People is an ideal choice for people with sensitive skin that's prone to allergic reactions. This pencil is as good as Ecco Bella option.

It comes in four different shades (black, brown, purple, and blue) combining deep color and nourishment for your skin. The non-toxic, vegan ingredients like jojoba oil, rhus verniciflua peel wax and hydrogenated coco glycerides provide a deep, creamy texture with a glossy finish as well as eyelid care and hydration.

#3 Hush + Dotti Organic Liquid Eyeliner

100% The Best Organic Liquid Eyeliner.

Hush + Dotti is one of The Best Organic Eyeliner. A proud winner of Byrdie's 2019 Eco Beauty Award, this natural liquid eyeliner smoothly glides across the lashes. It also lasts all day and it's easy to use. Made from vitamin E and aloe vera extract, it's gentle on the skin, easy to take off and truly water-proof.

Probably the best all-natural eyeliner, it's certified organic and ethically sourced within the USA. It also contains rosemary leaf and chamomile flower extract, as well as behenic acid (a distillate of naturally occurring vitamin C) to soothe and protect your skin. Shake it well before applying to get the best results.

#4 Benecos Natural Eyeliner

Vegan, affordable, and available in nine beautiful colors, the natural eyeliner made by Benecos is a strong candidate for the best organic eye pencil. It's safe for all skin types, even if you're prone to allergies.

Glides on easily but doesn't slide off until you want it to. The main ingredient of this vegan eyeliner is jojoba oil, but it's also rich in vitamin E and vitamin C, as well as other antioxidants for gentle skin nourishment and a soft, reliable, water-proof texture.

#5 100% Pure Creamy Long Last Natural Eyeliner

Finding a safe eyeliner pencil that performs well without being filled with toxins can be a challenge. These 100% Pure products come pretty close to being the best natural eyeliners.

Made with certified natural ingredients, including black tea and aloe vera as well as oregano leaf, rosemary, and suckle flower, they're a perfect choice for sensitive skin and eyes. Shea butter deeply moisturizes your skin, while vitamin E (tocopherol) protects from free radical damage.

These eyeliners offer a silky texture, don't leave smudges, and have a beautiful fruity smell.

#6 Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner - Best Waterproof Organic Liquid Eyeliner

If you're looking for the best natural eyeliner out there, you should consider this natural option by Zuzu Luxe.

Available in eight beautiful color shades, this fantastic eyeliner is water-resistant, vegan, and gluten-free. The formula features aloe vera leaf juice and eyebright extract for soothing skincare along with quick drying.

The fine calligraphy tip ensures perfect precision, just make sure you gently shake it before applying for perfect color consistency.

#7 Naturalmente Breathe Liquid Eyeliner

Made in Italy exclusively from natural ingredients grown with organic farming, Naturalmente's Breathe eyeliner features antibacterial and antifungal properties of Salvia sclarea combined with plant-derived Squalane for protection and nourishment of your skin.

The flexible brush ensures easy application with sharp, clear lines that are water-proof and stay on as long as you want them to. Shake well before applying to mix the oils with powder components for best results.

#8 Ilia Pure Eyeliner

Available in five beautiful shades, this eyeliner saves you from having to sharpen it before use. The handy twist-up application has a built-in sharpener so you'll get a gorgeous, defined look every single time.

Ilia's eyeliners are made with healing vitamin E and avocado oils, alongside soothing shea and coconut butter, offering protection for the delicate skin around the eye. Enjoy the rich, creamy colors that glide with ease and are buildable and blendable for a perfect look. May contain mica and iron oxide.

#9 Au Naturale Swipe-On Essential Eye Pencil

The best organic eye pencil for those with extremely sensitive skin. Available in eight amazing colors for any occasion, from subtle Deep Sea to classic black Night.

Made from castor seed oil (moisture and pigment), calming jojoba seed oil, and candelilla wax, the go-to vegan substitute for beeswax.

Au Naturale's eyeliners can be sharpened for precise definition, or used with a blending tool for a seductive smudge look. They're 100% natural, cruelty-free and vegan, so they're great for all skin types, including oily skin. May contain titanium dioxide and mica.

#10 Jillian Dempsey Natural Khôl Organic Eyeliner - Best Non Toxic Eyeliner

Everyone likes products that can serve more than one purpose and this amazing pencil can double as a pretty decent alternative to eyeshadow. Available in Jet Black, Rich Brown, Black Sapphire with a hint of blue, and sophisticated Deep Burgundy.

The pencil also features a built-in smudging tool for smooth application and a sultry look. Organic ingredients include hydrogenated jojoba oil, shea butter, and candelilla wax, offering gentle nourishment for your eyelids. This eyeliner is also water-proof, provides fantastic color intensity and is preservative-free.

Other Options for Best Organic Eyeliner

BeautyCounter Precision Liquid Liner

Combining a dense, matte black color with safe ingredients, this eyeliner offers easy and precise application for every imaginable look, from thin, edgy lines to thick, dramatic wings just by applying a bit more pressure. Lasts up to 12 hours without smudging or transferring to your eyelids. The formula features all-natural ingredients that are safe for all skin types.

Neutrogena Nourishing Natural Eyeliner

When it comes to natural eyeliner brands, you can't go wrong with Neutrogena. Their products have been around for decades and it's the number one skincare brand if you ask dermatologists. This hypoallergenic eyeliner features a rich formula with olive oil and shea butter for skin nourishment. The built-in sharpener ensures effortless application, while the smudger softens and blends for that perfect smoky eye look. Available in four beautiful shades with long-lasting results that won't smudge or fade for hours.

Jane Iredale Liquid Eyeliner

Another big name when it comes to natural eyeliner brands, Jane Iredale offers a eyeliner that features saturated color and impressive staying power without the burden of irritation and harmful chemicals. Packed with essential oils and rosemary leaf extract to nourish your skin and prevent drying, this great vegan eyeliner is available in rich black and black/brown shades. Ideal for sensitive and hooded eyes as it won't transfer to your eyelids. For perfect results, shake the bottle before use.

Antonym Certified Natural Eye Pencil

Made with ingredients that are of 100% natural origin, preservative-free and dermatologically tested, this great eyeliner is safe to use even if you have sensitive skin and eyes. Antonym's classic black pencil features candelilla, carnauba, as well as jojoba oil and other natural antioxidants that provide gentle care for your skin. Enjoy the long-lasting, water-proof coverage and precise lines or a perfectly smudged smoky eye look.

Juice Beauty Phyto-Pigments Liquid Line & Define

Another top contender for the prestigious title of the best organic eyeliner, Phyto-Pigments offers intense black color with certified natural ingredients. Includes moisturizing cranberry seed oil, jojoba oil, and aloe juice with fantastic anti-inflammatory properties. Plant-derived phyto-pigments of cranberry, daisy, turmeric, and basil provide a rich, deep black color. The tip is easy to use, providing you with flexibility and precision to design the look you want, thick or thin, with a reliable smudge-proof formula for dramatic results. May contain iron oxides from natural sources.

NakedPoppy Liquid Eyeliner

Putting your health first while keeping an eye on animal and environmental health, NakedPoppy has created an all-natural eyeliner that glides on smooth and remains smudge-proof all day. It's also ophthalmologically tested and approved, certified cruelty-free, and vegan. Thanks to the fine-tip pen, a cat-eye swoosh becomes effortless. You also have a short amount of time for quick edits and corrections as the liner doesn't stick immediately.

Ere Perez Jojoba Eye Pencils

Available in ten amazing shades, from soft gold to classic black, this is the ideal natural eyeliner for people with very sensitive skin. The experts at this Australian-owned company carefully chose the ingredients to make an eyeliner that's gentle, effective and natural. Made from a delicate jojoba and coconut oil combination that's gentle on your eyes, protecting your eyelids and enhancing lash growth. Enjoy vibrant colors, durability, and easy application. In case the pencil gets soft, throw it in the fridge to harden it up. May contain iron oxides.

Vapour Organic Beauty Mesmerize Eyeliner

Another great two-in-one product, this pencil features a gentle sponge tool that allows you to blend your liner for an amazing smoky look. This certified organic pencil liner is packed with vitamins and minerals offering gentle care for your skin without any aging or irritating chemicals found in conventional products. Enjoy the soothing nourishment of coconut and chamomile, as well as sunflower and palm oil for ultimate hydration. Mesmerize Eyeliner comes in two shades (black and brown), it's easy to apply and remove, which makes it one of the best organic eyeliners out there.

BaeBlu Organic Eyeliner Gel Pot

Make your eyes stand out with this versatile organic eyeliner gel. It's an ideal choice for every imaginable look, easy to apply, and stays on reliably without smudging or running. Featuring an organic, vegan, completely natural formula that's free of synthetic ingredients, it's great for sensitive eyes and easily irritable skin. Contains castor seed oil, grape seed oil, carnauba and candelilla wax for gentle skin nourishment and care.

Kjaer Weis Organic Eye Pencils

Certified by the European Organic Certifiers Council (EOCC), these pencils come in five shades (peach, brown, blue, purple, and black). Combining luxurious looks and safe ingredients, this eyeliner is made of the finest natural, organic, gluten-free materials, including coconut oil, candelilla wax, and hydrogenated vegetable oil. They offer a soft and smooth feel without smudging and can be applied directly for defined lines or with the Kjaer Weis Angle Brush for a softer look.

Honest Liquid Eyeliner

Designed with a flexible tip for precise application and ultimate control, this liner combines clean lines and ultra-pigmented inky black color that won't smudge or flake for up to 8 hours. Suitable for all sorts of looks, from thin and defined to a dramatic blend. Made from natural plant-derived ingredients, it's vegan and cruelty-free. Goes well with all types of skin as it's hypoallergenic and ophthalmologically tested.

Alima Pure Pressed Eyeshadow

Available in 14 beautiful colors, this product by Alima Pure offers an ideal way to achieve a soft, subtle liner. Made in Italy, featuring a creamy powder texture, it blends easily for a long-lasting finish on your eyelids or as a liner. The all-natural vegan formula includes avocado oil for hydration and epidermal elasticity, vitamin-rich rice powder and jojoba oil to stimulate collagen production. Doesn't contain gluten, nuts, silicone, parabens or any other synthetic ingredients.

W3ll People Expressionist Organic Eyeliner Liquid

This is one of the Best Organic Eyeliner 2021 year. When it comes to reliable organic eyeliner, W3ll People is always a safe bet. The go-to choice for many celebrities, this liquid eyeliner is made with premium natural, organic ingredients. Enjoy the soothing nourishment of organic rosemary and aloe vera leaf juice in this vegan, hypoallergenic, and noncomedogenic eyeliner. The fine felt tip applicator provides ultimate precision that won't fade or smudge. For best results, wait 20 seconds for it to dry and set properly for lasting wear.

Omiana Black Long-Stay Vegan Cream Eyeliner Pot

This vivid black eyeliner is suitable for any look, ranging from barely visible to extremely thick. The pot allows more control, so you can use a thin brush for precise, sharp lines or a wider brush to blend as needed. An ideal choice even for sensitive eyes, the chemical-free formula is packed with organic ingredients and unmatched staying power. Coconut and grape seed oil combined with vitamin E and cinnamon bark extract offer nourishment for all types of skin.

100% Pure Long Last Liquid Eye Liner

An award-winning liner by 100% Pure, this is probably the best natural liquid eyeliner I've tried. Ideal for sensitive eyes, it comes in three rich, dramatic colors (blackberry, dark chocolate, black tea) and features a long-lasting, water-resistant, and smudge-proof formula. All three shades are made with natural ingredients, including sunflower seed oil that prevents acne and inflammation, vitamin E for nourishment, and marula oil, a powerful antioxidant that's great for dry skin. As the name suggests, it lasts all day, and it's free of artificial ingredients, chemicals, and petrochemical dyes.

Avril Certified Organic Eyeliner Eye Pencil

Featuring an amazing combination of a price you just can't beat and completely organic ingredients, Avril offers their fantastic eye pencil in no less than fourteen different shades. From classic black to more exotic colors like green, Avril has everything covered, so you can experiment with new, bold looks and combinations without breaking the bank. The all-natural formula features ingredients from organic farming, ensures precise lines and long-lasting results that are perfect for sensitive eyes.

bareMinerals One Fine Line Micro Precision Eyeliner

Featuring an ultra-fine 1.5 mm tip, this is probably the thinnest eyeliner in this list, allowing for perfect application at the lash line and the eye's inner rim. Formulated with mineral pigments for long-lasting color and a beautifully soft matte finish. Naturally sourced carnauba wax allows for a perfect glide without dragging or tugging. Perfect for tight lines as well as a classic cat-eye look. We've all been in a situation where we don't have time for anything too complicated. If all you need is a subtle matte black etching across the lash line, this precise pencil offers just that without any hassle or fuss.

Hynt Beauty FORTE High Definition Eyeliner

Made with organic ingredients and offering a luxurious feel, this is a fantastic chemical-free eyeliner. The gentle and smooth formulation makes it a perfect choice for sensitive skin. As for the ingredients, it features coconut and vegetable oils for a creamy texture, easy application, and lasting results. The pencil includes a smudge tip if you want to go for a more dramatic smoky look. It's a perfect addition to your makeup bag, available in black and brown, and approved by PETA.

Aveda Petal Essence Eye Definer

Define and accentuate your eyes and eyebrows with this blendable, creamy, smooth formula by Aveda. Available in four different shades, this eyeliner features aromatic flower waxes (jasmine and geranium) for a soft texture and vibrant color that's harmless for the delicate skin around your eyes. Candelilla and carnauba wax ensure the liner is durable and stays on without smudging. Ophthalmologically tested and made from responsibly sourced wood, it's the perfect choice for the sustainability-minded.

Lily Lolo Natural Eye Pencil

Don't let the affordable price fool you, this natural eyeliner pencil is a fantastic product. Lily Lolo is a London-based company producing 100% natural makeup with delicate skin in mind, and this eyeliner is no exception. Featuring tried and true organic moisturizing and conditioning ingredients like shea butter, jojoba oil, and vitamin E, it glides on smoothly and without tugging. Available in black and brown, this amazing pencil eyeliner is free from chemicals, artificial dyes, and fillers.

RMS Beauty Vintage Cake Liner

For something a bit different in terms of packaging and application, consider this dark black cake eyeliner by RMS Beauty. Delivering rich pigment for flawless definition, you can wear it as a cat-eye or smudge it out for a sultry matte shadow or intense smoky look. The non-GMO formula features cocoa seed butter, algin, sorbic acid, and other all-natural ingredients that make it safe for all skin types, easy to apply and stay in place all day.

Jane Iredale Eye Pencil

Available in seven luxurious shades, this all-natural eyeliner offers subtle, soft or dramatic lines along with protection and hydration of your delicate eyelid skin. Available in seven different shades, this eye pencil has all the classic colors covered. Featuring a mineral-based formula with conditioning oils, including moisturizing shea butter and vitamin E, as well as natural pigments for lasting color. As long as you're gentle during sharpening, this pencil eyeliner won't let you down.

Inika Organic COCO Eye Pencil

Australian owned, 100% vegan, certified organic and cruelty-free, Inika offers a wide variety of beauty products including their organic liquid eyeliner. Available in nine gorgeous colors, this organic eye pencil is packed with natural plant-based ingredients and mineral pigments. The easy-glide formula helps achieve dramatic looks without any effort. The eyeliner lasts all day and it's suitable for sensitive skin as it's packed with vegetable and coconut oils for additional nourishment.

Physicians Formula Eye Booster 2-in-1 Eyeliner & Serum

Finding the best hypoallergenic eyeliner available can be troublesome with so many products out there, but Physicians Formula has a product that comes pretty close. Derived from a Japanese formula, this interesting combo enhances your lashes and speeds up their growth while providing water and smudge-resistant eyeliner at the same time. The Eye Booster doesn't contain artificial fragrances or paraben, it's approved by dermatologists, safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens users. Unfortunately, it smears relatively easy and doesn't last as long as other products on this list.

Burt's Bees Nourishing Eyeliner

Natural, affordable, and free of toxic ingredients used by conventional brands, Burt's Bees Nourishing Eyeliner is a strong contender for the best organic eyeliner. Made from mango, jojoba, and cottonseed for gentle skin nourishment. Even the pencil itself is crafted from responsibly sourced wood. Available in three distinct shades (Midnight Gray, Soft Black, and Warm Brown), this eyeliner is smudge-proof, reliable, and safe for contact lens users.

Alima Pure Natural Definition Eye Pencil

Made in the Czech Republic, this chemical-free eyeliner comes in three distinct colors (Ink, Patina, and Coffee), offering high pigmentation from natural sources and impressive durability, especially when combined with a translucent powder. Formulated with soothing plant-based jojoba, cottonseed, and meadow seed oils for a smooth and hassle-free application, as well as tried and true chamomile flower for skin protection. It might be important to note that it contains nuts.

Inika Organic Certified Liquid Eyeliner

Inika, one of the best organic eyeliner, features all-natural ingredients in this stunning organic liquid liner. Made from black tea leaf extract, aloe vera, and natural mineral pigments for rich color and longevity. The star of the show, aloe vera, has incredible healing properties as it's rich with minerals and antioxidants. Available in black and brown variants, this liquid eyeliner provides intense, smudge-proof color while the precision tip allows faultless application. Certified vegan and cruelty-free.

VERT Beauty Organic Eyeliner

If you're looking for the best non-toxic eyeliner out there, you should consider this vegan product by VERT. Available in five colors for diverse looks, from subtle to dramatic, this eyeliner is infused with a powerful anti-aging mix of meadowfoam, mango and candelilla seed oil. It's easy to apply, glides on perfectly without smudging or tugging, and is available in five vibrant colors. Enjoy the anti-inflammatory properties of jojoba oil and the all-natural minerals for a hint of shimmer.

Hush + Dotti Organic Gel Liner

If liquid and pencil eyeliners aren't your thing, Hush + Dotti has just the thing. You don't have to be a professional to use this non-toxic eyeliner, all you need is a brush. The organic gel-based eyeliner formula offers natural, smooth lines and just glides across your lashes. It's water-proof and a perfect choice for people with sensitive eyes, as well as contact lens users. Made from coconut, grape, and castor oils, along with thyme and cinnamon bark extracts to nourish and protect your skin and reduce acne. Probably the best organic gel eyeliner, it's perfect for daily use.

Jane Iredale Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner

In case you prefer powdered eyeliners over other types, Jane Iredale has a natural product for you. Available in six rich colors in a stunning powder/cream mix, you can create the look you love with ease. The powder is already slightly wet so no preparation is necessary. The built-in brush creates perfect lines as well as a flawless smudged smoky eye that's water-resistant and durable. If you're looking for a powdered solution that's vegan and contains natural ingredients, look no further.

Final Thoughts

No matter which type of eyeliner you prefer, their purpose is the same — to accentuate your eyes. An actual window to the soul is the most prominent feature of one's face and the first thing you notice on a person.

Since eyeliners' primary purpose is to offer a specific look by bringing vibrant, defining color and a dash of glamour to light up your eyes, they're often water-proof for increased durability. These two characteristics often make eyeliner manufacturers use harmful (or toxic) ingredients that are usually not present in other cosmetic products. 

Chemicals can cause intense irritation, skin damage, speed up aging, or even lead to skin cancer if used excessively. It doesn't have to be that way.

This is where organic products step in. Only the Best Organic Eyeliner made from natural, healthy, environmentally sound ingredients can provide a wide variety of benefits for your skin. It's the perfect way to get the look you want for any occasion and supply your skin with the care and nourishment it deserves. I sincerely hope this research helped "open your eyes" to all the advantages a organic eyeliner can provide.

FAQ's On Best Organic Eyeliner

Ecco Bella Soft Eyeliner Pencil

Ecco Bella has you covered if you're looking for an organic eyeliner pencil that's environmentally friendly and won't irritate your skin. Creating natural products since 1992, their priority is your health and the health of our environment. Rich in palm kernel glycerides, this fantastic eyeliner comes in five colors and offers smooth lines, softly defining your eyes without tugging. Made from vegetable wax, without petroleum oils, the formula is certified vegan as well as gluten-free. Even though it's a soft pencil, you can easily sharpen it without crumbling. A strong contender for the best organic eye pencil, creating a fantastic smudged cover, as well as clear and defined lines when sharpened.

Product SKU: B000URVDKY

Product Brand: Ecco Bella

Product Currency: $

Product Price: 17.95

Price Valid Until: 2022-05-01

Product In-Stock: InStock

Editor's Rating:
{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
The Top 10 Best Organic Mascara

The 10 Best Organic Mascara

Best Organic Eye Creams

The 10 Best Organic Eye Creams

best organic makeup removers

8 Best Organic Makeup Removers

10 Best Organic and Natural Concealers

The 10 Best Organic Concealers

organic makeup for kids

Organic Makeup For Kids

best organic eyeshadow

The 20 Best Organic Eyeshadows